|
二星fun會員
 
|
1#
大 中
小 發表於 2009-2-12 02:09 只看該作者
《聖訴》觀後感
聖訴(doubt) ，想不到的精彩。
精彩的是情節簡單但劇力迫人。在一間教會學校裡，Father Flynn(菲臘西摩荷夫曼飾演)被Sister Aloysius(梅麗史翠普飾演)在沒有真憑實據下誣告侵犯兒童。一個大聲呼冤，一個堅信直覺，劇情就在這種矛盾下發展，兩人沒有動刀動槍，只憑連場唇槍舌劍去牽動觀眾情緒，看來它是成功的，因為絕無冷場。
精彩的是兩位演技派的「鬥戲」，梅麗史翠普繼《穿Prada的惡魔》後，又再一次以惡死cool樣示人，質詢神父時的咄咄迫人，堅持相信自己直覺的一臉自負，都令人留下深刻印象；菲臘西摩荷夫曼飾演的「疑似戀童」神父也入型入格，被迫供時面部不流露半點表情，令人猜不透他究竟是忠是奸。後來在講道時借題發揮，寸爆對手也真的叫人拍案叫絕。
精彩的是對白的雋永。特別欣賞Father Flynn在講道時提及胡亂散佈謠言的害處。他將謠言比喻作飄散空中的羽毛。當你想收回已說出的謠言時，恐怕沒有可能，因為它們已飄到城裡每個角落了。原文摘錄如下：A woman who'd been gossiping about her neighbor had a dream where a large hand was pointing down at her, pressing upon her chest. Upset, she went to the priest and asked him if gossiping was a sin. Her harsh confessor is one Father O'Rourke who upbraids her severely for misappropriating the truth and assassinating the character of her neighbor. For penance the priest tells her to take a feather pillow to the rooftop of the building where she lives and cut it open, permitting the wind to carry the feathers everywhere. The woman does so and returns to the priest, presumably seeking absolution. The priest now instructs the gossip to retrieve every feather wherever it has been blown by the wind. The gossip tells Father O'Rourke that this is impossible, for she cannot possibly know where every feather has been carried by the wind! "And that is gossip," says Father O'Rourke.
精彩的是那個無言的結局。Sister Aloysius看似在這場「猜疑的遊戲」中獲勝，但更大的doubt卻隨之而來，迫得她失聲痛哭……言有盡，意無窮。她懷疑的究竟是甚麼？是自己一直的行為模式嗎？還是懷疑一直信靠的上帝？還在思索中。如果你也看過，不妨討論一下。
Welcome to visit my blog. http://lonelykiller0505.spaces.live.com 
|
