發新話題
打印

校際音樂比賽出現非常評判

校際音樂比賽出現非常評判

本人從事音樂工作超過二十年,經常鼓勵學生參加香港學校音樂節,這個比賽過去具有一定的認受性。可惜,今屆音樂節出現一位令人失望的評判——MR YAU LIM,本人希望與各位分享一下

由MR YAU LIM評核的十一歲以下中文歌唱個別組別,共有超過四十位參賽者,結果在全場參賽者中,竟然沒有一位能得到八十分或以上,即沒有人得到基本的「良好」級別,參賽者平均只得七十三分,最後冠亞季全數落空!我不相信,亦不相信有人會相信,在云云參賽者之中都沒有一位學生值得取八字頭的分數!校際比賽辦了超過六十年,八十分相等於什麼水平,大家心中都有個認知。是次事件,顯然是評判的問題。
那些參賽者都是十一歲以下,多給予鼓勵才能培養出一份自信。試問參賽者做錯何事,用得著要給予狠狠的回報?參賽者得到分紙後如何向老師家長交代?這對家長來說是一種打擊,對老師來說是一種侮辱。與其他音樂界的朋友討論,同時發現這位評判,亦擔任合唱組別的評核工作,該合唱組別最後亦是三甲落空,真正難為了各位勞心勞力的指揮與同學們。
這位評判,如此獨具慧眼,本人很想了解他有多厲害,經過查核,他來自新加坡,是一位指揮家。請問是否新加坡學生的音樂造詣極高,令評判認為香港的學生表現如此不堪?他那套評分準則,是有意踐踏香港抬高新加坡,抑或踐踏學生抬高自己?                                                                                                                                                                                                                       

TOP

http://www.tpo.org.sg/about_us/music_director_lim_yau



Singapore-born Lim Yau is Resident Conductor of Singapore Symphony Orchestra and Music Director of the Singapore Symphony Chorus, a dual appointment he assumed in January 2001. Previously, he served the Singapore Symphony Orchestra as Associate Conductor and the Chorus Master (1981-1997). He was also the Principal Guest Conductor of the Shanghai Philharmonic Orchestra and Chorus from 1993 to 1997. In 1997 he became Music Director of the Singapore Lyric Opera and in 1998, founded the Philharmonic Chamber Orchestra which soon developed into an outstanding ensemble.

Notable recent performances include concerts and recordings with the Singapore Symphony Orchestra and Chorus, the Shanghai Philharmonic Orchestra and Chorus, the Shanghai Symphony Orchestra, the Orchestra of National Opera and Ballet, China, the Guangzhou Symphony Orchestra, the Philippines Philharmonic, the State Philharmonic of Tirgu Mures, Satu Mare and Constanta in Romania, the State Symphony of Krasnayarsk, the Russian Philharmonic, The Philippines Madrigal Singers, the Lund University Male Chorus (Sweden), as well as the Latvian State Choir.

Besides regularly conducting orchestras and choruses in Europe and Asia, Lim Yau is also active in Singapore systematically promoting opera, ballet, contemporary music and choral excellence. He has conducted no less than 20 opera and ballet productions for the Singapore Lyric Opera and Singapore Dance Theatre in works ranging from Britten to Verdi. A keen advocate of Singaporean composers, he has given first performances of more than 30 new compositions for opera, orchestra, chamber ensemble and a capella chorus. His passion and enthusiasm for choral music led him to the formation of The Philharmonic Chorus , which has emerged as one of the most prominent chamber choirs in the region.

Lim Yau graduated from the Royal College of Music and Guildhall School of Music and Drama in London and also had the privilege of working under mentors such as Sergio Celibidache in Munich and Franco Ferrara in Sienna.

In recognition of his contribution to music in Singapore, Lim Yau was awarded the Cultural Medallion in 1990.                                                                                                                                                                                                                       

TOP

請問有冇比賽片斷可以 link 上嚟???

睇返邱生嘅資歷, 佢對聲樂應該幾有研究, 講真, 香港 D 學生唱歌乜嘢質素, 開埠以來出過幾多位國際級歌唱家, 大家心照啦, 以往咁易攞八十分會唔會係放水放得太鬆???


與其睇成侮辱, 倒不如視為對香港學界嘅鞭策, 等老師同學生都提高自己要求, 咁香港音樂界嘅水準至會不斷進步。

                                                                                                                                                                                                                       

TOP

如何佢評慣世界級比賽,就唔好黎做校際比賽評判LA

TOP

可能harsh左少少
不過呢d野一向主觀                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               

TOP

香港學生嘅歌唱水平同其他地區比較, 以下兩段片可作參考:

CPU Treble Choir 06/07 - Spring Song

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KXLmjZilhYk&fmt=18


This is the Prize-Winners' Recital of the 59th Schools Music Festival held by the HKSMSA.

CPU Treble Choir 06/07 has got the NT Most Outstanding Secondary School Junior Choir and the NT Most Outstanding Secondary School Choir in the 59th Schools Music Festival. This is one of the songs they had sung.


Pollard Middle School Treble Choir - Metsa Telegramm


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rARnhbGIHE0&fmt=18


Pollard Middle School Treble Choir performing Metsa Telegramm at the Hershey, PA "Music in the Parks" music festival on May 3, 2008








                                                                                                                                                                                                                       

TOP

校際久唔久都會出現呢D"另類"評判,遇到佢當唔好彩囉
呢位評判似乎不是一位音樂教育家,對音樂教育有幾多料? 我唔知道, 但可以肯定對香港學界情況不了解
樓上的仁兄應該不是從事本地音樂教育工作吧

TOP

其實香港細路唱歌唔差, 香港兒童合唱團有好高水準(葉博士時代). 但到中學後就因為'學業 & 工作 $$$$'理由, 就無.... 所以開埠以來無出過幾多位國際級歌唱家. 新加坡人性格一向要求高, 在他們心目中小朋友永遠做不好 ... 但現代的香港兒童合唱團比十九幾年前差左好多.

TOP

發新話題